How to Choose the Best Manufacturer for your Product

How to Choose the Best Manufacturer for your Product
Image via

Image source: Pixabay via Pexels

Many companies choose to not have their products made in-house, and instead outsourcing to a manufacturer. Choosing to outsource manufacturing can be advantageous for several reasons, such as if you and your co-founders lack the proper technical knowledge, if your company doesn’t want to front the costs for purchasing manufacturing equipment, if your company doesn’t possess the manpower, or simply doesn’t want to put in that much trial and error time and would rather leave it up to a manufacturing professional.

If you don’t have a strong technical background or are unsure of what your product’s requirements are, contacting a manufacturer can be intimidating.

Here are a few key factors and questions that every entrepreneur and business leader should consider before choosing the best manufacturer for your product:

Number One Rule

Like everything in life, having options automatically puts one at a place of advantage. I highly recommend procuring quotes from an average of five manufacturers (at the VERY minimum three). This will give you an idea of where the mid-range pricing and lead time falls for making your product and will also set you up for a place of price negotiation. If you know your product can be produced several ways, I would also recommend reaching out to manufacturers that utilize both processes to see which method of producing your product is less expensive and more time efficient.

Noting Follow-Up Response Time

How quickly does the company get back to you when you are initially reaching out and requesting a quote? This can be an early on indicator of how punctual and attentive this manufacturer will be throughout your relationship.

Are They Asking YOU Questions?

From my experience, a good manufacturing company will ask you concise, thoughtful questions about your expectations and the product requirements. This shows that they are considerate of their customer’s expectations, and how the can best meet these expectations. Bottom line: a good manufacturer knows that it is always better to ask questions initially, rather than go through the trouble of fixing an order later on, and failing to do so should be a red flag.

Request a List of References

Ask if they can provide a list of current or past customers as references. Reach out and ask them how satisfied they were with the quality of the parts they received and whether their orders were met in a timely manner. Other additionally useful questions would be about whether they found the customer service to be satisfactory, and whether they would use this manufacturer again in the future.

Weighing Tooling Cost vs Part Cost

Any startup who is bootstrapping will want to get the best bang for their buck, especially when in the early product development stages. When receiving a quote, generally pricing for tooling and price per part will be listed separately. If your company intends on making large orders in the future, then it may be worth going with a manufacturer who quotes a higher tooling price, but lower price per part, rather than a company who quotes a mid-range tooling price, but a higher price per part. If you plan on making very few parts, it is likely better to choose the manufacturer who quotes the lowest tooling cost.

Lead time

The lead time factor is critical for obtaining your parts in a timely manner so you can begin fulfilling customer orders and generating revenue. Obtaining a good combination of price and lead time for your budget and timeline is an important thing to consider when choosing a manufacturer. If your company is currently not in a time-sensitive stage of growth – maybe you have other business factors that need to be taken care of prior to launching the product, then focusing more keeping tooling and part costs low may be more beneficial, as it can sometimes be a tradeoff of lead time.

First Article Approval and Payment Plans

Another thing that should be asked of potential manufacturers is whether they offer first article approval and what payment options are available. First article approval is when a manufacturer ensures that their customer is satisfied with the first part(s) made before proceeding to produce the full order. Though this doesn’t always prevent tooling issues, it can help identify part mistakes early on. Additionally, asking whether the full payment must be made upfront, or whether it can be made in installments (i.e. 50% with first order, 25% at delivery of first articles, and 25% at approval of first articles) is important for knowing whether this works for your budget, and how to plan your budget for meeting payment installments later on.

Do They Have a Minimum Order Requirement?

If your company only needs a small order of parts initially, check to see if the manufacturer you’re interested in has a minimum order requirement, and whether this fits your order size.

Do They Offer Prototyping Options?

Manufacturing can be an expensive process, if you are not completely sure about the requirements of your product (maybe the material or how thick you need your part to be for it to function properly), it is worth asking whether the manufacturer can make a couple initial prototypes with small variances in the factors you are unsure of. Using less expensive, softer tooling to test your part out and discover hidden issues before transcending into a full-scale order will save money and heartache later on. Some manufacturers will do this for a small fee, and it is worth seeing whether this option is available.

Because manufacturing is often a timely and expensive aspect of business, it is well worth the energy to make sure the company you ultimately choose will be able to meet your requirements and produce a quality, cost-effective product. The more prepared you are ahead of time, the more likely you will make the right choice. Good luck!