Longevity of the Entrepreneurial Spirit
Interview with Dr Carlo Salvato, Professor of Business Strategy at Bocconi University’s Department of Management and Technology, Italy
By Lee Hoverd
While no simple numerical threshold exists to determine longevity in the family business, Professor Carlo Salvato believes that there are two distinct ways to look at the phenomenon.
In his view, the second type of longevity, the one we are perhaps less apt to celebrate or recognise as such, furthers generational continuity even more so than the conventional one-family one-business model, especially in a disrupted world.
Typically, longevity is measured by the number of years or generations that a family has been in business. However, in some cases, families have owned several businesses over the years then sold or folded them, only to begin again, and they are not necessarily less successful than their peers. Businesses are linear, but entrepreneurship is cyclical. According to Professor Salvato, families set themselves up for longstanding success when they favour entrepreneurial spirit over the preservation of a single company or product, especially in rapidly changing business environments.
We spoke with Professor Salvato about broadening our definition of longevity and the challenge of quantifying success through generations.
How do you define longevity when it comes to family businesses?
I believe longevity refers to the continuity of a family firm, beyond the career span of its founders. However, that implies just a single full generation of ownership, which many family businesses would not consider longevity. The age of a company, its year of founding and the number of generations involved while controlled by a family is often used to define its longevity, but much of those criteria depend on uneven regional characteristics and cultural conventions.
Longevity is a complex concept and difficult to quantify when it comes to family businesses. Often, the definition is subjective: how a family feels about their business or what a specific industry or country believes constitutes longevity is the deciding factor.
Dr Carlo Salvato; image courtesy of the subject
Dr Carlo Salvato; image courtesy of the subject
Exploring how to structure and manage your collective assets and wealth in turbulent times.
Leading the Family Office
May 26-28, 2021
imd.org/lfo
What can family businesses teach us about longevity that other organisations cannot?
The strength and quality of relationships that family firms are capable of developing stands out to me the most. Other successful companies have some quality relationships to be sure, but relationships in family firms are unique and grounded on characteristics that extend beyond a quid pro quo exchange.
Self-interest does exist in family firms — it would be impossible to build multi-generational success without it — but family businesses can’t think exclusively about their own interests like other business entities can.
For example, there are financially beneficial behaviours that other businesses engage in that family firms can’t. Behaviours such as firing employees, not paying fair market salaries, not making timely payments to banks or not paying taxes offer short term advantages to companies, but family businesses have to think long term. It’s their family name, reputation and standing in the community that must also be considered and protected.
Family firms realise that eventually, they will need the support of their communities, employees, banks and local governments. Maintaining these strong relationships serves family businesses in the long run, as does keeping quality relationships within the family and the wider stakeholder group.
What kind of strategies indicate that families want to stay in business for generations to come?
Image by Eric Muhr on Unsplash
Image by Eric Muhr on Unsplash
I'll begin by saying that when families set longevity, at least in the conventional sense, as a goal, they are usually thinking about the past, not the future. Often, they do it to preserve the amount of social and emotional capital they have put into the business. Research indicates that sometimes, families will make decisions that appear irrational to on their way to that goal — those decisions that are based on emotional wealth rather than economic wealth. Not all strategic decisions driven by a goal of longevity are economically sound.
Generally, there are two strategies that family firms employ when longevity becomes their primary objective.
The first strategy involves keeping the family’s business name and preserving their brand as much as possible. In some cases, this means eschewing new directions or profitable segments to maintain a family’s brand image. Similarly, this can influence diversification strategies when a family doesn’t want to be associated with a certain product or service. Keeping the name and preserving the brand is one of the ways that longevity affects decision making.
The second strategy families use in pursuit of longevity is selective and adaptive staffing of their company’s top positions. That doesn’t necessarily mean choosing the best possible manager available, but rather, selecting someone who will allow the company to be controlled by the family and who will stick to its history and heritage — frequently, someone who is averse to change. In some cases, this approach leads to families changing CEOs every couple of years as soon as they feel their CEO's actions are out of alignment with family and company values. These families feel that maintaining strict consistency is critical for their business to survive multiple generations, which can be good for maintaining direction, but can also be harmful. These families don’t get the benefit of leveraging managerial talent and experience, or the sometimes positive breath of fresh air executives with diverse backgrounds can add.
Image by Ylanite Koppens on Pexels
Image by Ylanite Koppens on Pexels
With the extraordinary pace of change in today’s business environment, is longevity still realistic?
There have always been revolutions and challenges. A hundred years ago, families were facing something that, just like today, made them question their ability to run their businesses. Even with those obstacles, however, which in the 20th Century meant world wars, family firms managed to keep their agendas and their longevity.
Today’s challenges are certainly different than the ones they faced a hundred years ago, but a shift in the interpretation of longevity can help serve families just as it has in the past. By focusing exclusively on the business itself, families continually bump up against the chaos of the times. However, if they interpret longevity as being more about the entrepreneurial spirit and less about a specific company, families can adapt and maintain continuity regardless of changing landscapes; it’s really about shifting their perception of what defines success for their family and its business interests.
Image by Mike on Pexels
Image by Mike on Pexels
How much emphasis should families put on longevity when educating the next generation?
Image by Skitterphoto on Pexels
Image by Skitterphoto on Pexels
Again, I think it depends on what aspect of longevity they stress. The longevity of a product is dangerous. Next-gens often see their seniors’ successes in terms of a product as boring; something that they can’t update or innovate is wholly unattractive. However, focusing on the longevity of the entrepreneurial spirit and entrepreneurial commitment to the family creates something much more enticing. It’s a goal that stimulates entrepreneurial energy and creativity in the minds of young next-generation members, and in doing so it creates an opportunity in addressing future crises that might impact specific industries.
Aside from that, there are practical ways of incentivising longevity when seen through the lens of the family and its entrepreneurial goals. For example, providing seed capital to support next-gen entrepreneurial ideas, regardless of whether they are related to the family business is a good way of attracting next-generation members and getting them to contribute to the longevity of the family in business.
That said, for any longevity strategy to work, family unity and the preservation of history is a must. Future generations draw inspiration from knowing that their father, grandfather, or grandmother made it with the support of the family. This imbues them with the belief that they can do it too. Like families themselves, the health and longevity of a family business hinges on the quality of the relationships in the family above all else.
